Reviewing The 2017 NFL Draft in 2018: #1 Myles Garrett, CLE vs. #8 Christian McCaffrey, CAR
We have a football season in the books and now we can look back and try to evaluate or re-evaluate the 2017 NFL Draft…and kinda re-remember what seemed important about a year ago – ultimately, to judge what would be done differently today or where teams made mistakes.
I like doing these types of things in head-to-head battles because it forces me to consider a simple choice…A or B. I can focus on the two players, get reacquainted with their 2017 season and pick the one I would select if I were an NFL GM today. I look at it like I’m starting an expansion franchise…so, I want the best player, obviously, but I have to consider positional scarcity and history, etc.
We’ll do one matchup per day in February until we crown a winner. Set up tournament style with 1-32 seed, and #1 facing #32 first round, etc.
#1 Myles Garrett, CLE vs. #8 Christian McCaffrey, CAR
I wouldn’t have expected McCaffrey to be in the Final 8, even though he was the #8 overall pick in 2017. He’s just a fortuitous player with his matchups/path to get here because he’s not one of the best 8 players in the 2017 NFL Draft. He’s a really good player but just a nice receiving weapon RB…there’s a bunch of them for anyone who is looking or who would actually use them like a weapon.
Somehow McCaffrey got anointed pre-Draft and thus the Panthers built a chunk of their offense doing something they hadn’t done during Cam’s entire time in Carolina – throwing a ton to the RB. I’m pro-McCaffrey but not pro-taking a part-time, 200-pound running back with a top 8 pick…in the most talent-laden position (RB) with the lowest payroll spend out there. It’s a ridiculous business move…but McCaffrey can really catch a football. He’s good.
On the other hand, there are only so many DE prospects built like Myles Garrett. He comes with flaws too, but there may be like 4-8 of him on the planet…and those rare species aren’t floating around available to NFL teams easily. However, I could find 20+ non-starter RBs in the NFL today that I could obtain cheap to fill the McCaffrey role close to or exactly.
Re-doing the 2017 draft with these two as a choice…it’s not debatable. Garrett is the way to go. Myles Garrett, #1 pick in 2017, makes it to the Final Four.
THIRD ROUND (Elite 8):
#1 Myles Garrett, CLE (winner) vs. #8 Christian McCaffrey, CAR
#28 Taco Charlton, DAL vs. #20 Garrett Bolles, DEN
#19 O.J. Howard, TB vs. #11 Marshon Lattimore, NO
#2 Mitch Trubisky, CHI vs. #10 Patrick Mahomes, KC
#1 Myles Garrett, CLE (winner) vs. #16 Marlon Humphrey, BAL
#24 Gareon Conley, OAK vs. #8 Christian McCaffrey, CAR (winner)
#12 Deshaun Watson, HOU vs. #28 Taco Charlton, DAL (winner)
#20 Garrett Bolles, DEN (winner) vs. #4 Leonard Fournette, JAX
#3 Solomon Thomas, SF vs. #19 O.J. Howard, TB (winner)
#27 Tre’Davious White, BUF vs. #11 Marshon Lattimore, NO (winner)
#26 Takkarist McKinley, ATL vs. #10 Patrick Mahomes, KC (winner)
#18 Adoree’ Jackson, TEN vs. #2 Mitch Trubisky, CHI (winner)
#1 Myles Garrett, CLE (winner) vs. #32 Ryan Ramczyk, NO
#16 Marlon Humphrey, BAL (winner)vs. #17 Jonathan Allen, WAS
#9 John Ross, CIN vs. #24 Gareon Conley, OAK (winner)
#8 Christian McCaffrey, CAR (winner)vs. #25 Jabrill Peppers, CLE
#12 Deshaun Watson, HOU (winner)vs. #21 Jarrad Davis, DET
#5 Corey Davis, TEN vs. #28 Taco Charlton, DAL (winner)
#13 Haason Reddick, ARI vs. #20 Garrett Bolles, DEN (winner)
#4 Leonard Fournette, JAX (winner) vs. #29 David Njoku, CLE
#3 Solomon Thomas, SF (winner) vs. #30 T.J. Watt, PIT
#14 Derek Barnett, PHI vs. #19 O.J. Howard, TB (winner)
#6 Jamal Adams, NYJ vs. #27 Tre’Davious White, BUF (winner)
#11 Marshon Lattimore, NO (winner) vs. #22 Charles Harris, MIA
#7 Mike Williams, LAC vs. #26 Takkarist McKinley, ATL (winner)
#10 Patrick Mahomes, KC (winner) vs. #23 Evan Engram, NYG
#15 Malik Hooker, IND vs. #18 Adoree’ Jackson, TEN (winner)
#2 Mitch Trubisky, CHI (winner) vs. #31 Rueben Foster, SF
See more of our football work at College Football Metrics – dedicated to the NFL Draft and Dynasty Rookie Draft scouting and valuations all preseason. Celebrating our 7th season covering all things draft. Go to (link): College Football Metrics
All rights reserved. All content is for entertainment purposes only and TFA is not responsible or liable for personal adverse outcomes nor are any game results or forecasting guaranteed. Past results do not predict future outcomes. We are not held liable for any personal loses incurred. We are solely here to produce and provide content for recreational purposes. No part of this publication may be reproduced, distributed, or transmitted in any form or by any means, including photocopying, recording, or other electronic or mechanical methods, without the prior written permission of the publisher, except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical reviews and certain other noncommercial uses permitted by copyright law. For permission requests, email the publisher at email@example.com.